Published Document

HSE Formal Complaint — Donal Carroll Mailbox

Documents displayed in this library have been explicitly marked as Published through the administrative workflow. Publication indicates intentional public availability. Publication does not certify legal status, evidential truth, or external validation.

Administrative Actions

This protected administrative action opens the existing authenticated workflow for creating a distinct canonical CDE record from this Published document.

Create canonical record from this document

Document Metadata

Title	HSE Formal Complaint — Donal Carroll Mailbox
Description	Raw MBOX export of the “Donal Carroll” submailbox within the complete HSE Formal Complaint mailbox export. It preserves four message records dated between 14 November and 15 December 2022 concerning a Trust in Care preliminary-screening outcome and subsequent registered-post correspondence. Preserved attachments include the Trust in Care policy, the preliminary-screening outcome letter, postal documentation, a call-related record and other supporting material. Forwarded and repeated material remains part of the original mailbox context.
Institution / Source	UL Hospitals Group Peri Operative Directorate — Apple Mail export from Nick Moloney’s Gmail mailbox
Category	Email mailbox archive
Keywords	HSE Formal Complaint · Donal Carroll · UL Hospitals Group · Peri Operative Directorate · Trust in Care · preliminary screening · registered post · postal delivery · complaint correspondence
Publication Date	2026-09-01
Document Date	2022-11-14
Document Format	MBOX Mailbox Archive
Media Type	Mailbox
SHA-256	8d8d83881b11fb9f700208fb7a18c7fa78c4a7056b78933331012bbabf668630
Document Identifier	DOC-2026-000431
Optional Reference Identifier	ULHG-COM.4338

Mailbox Overview

Parsed mailbox and message metadata reflects fields contained in the preserved MBOX archive. It does not independently establish mailbox completeness, sender identity, delivery, receipt, authorship, authenticity, factual accuracy, legal status, evidential sufficiency, or external validation. Contained messages remain projections of the preserved archive unless separately admitted through Document Intake.

Detected format	MBOX Mailbox Archive
Detected MBOX variant	mboxo
Message count	4
Parsed message count	4
Warning message count	1
Unparsed message count	0
Attachment total	10
Earliest message date recorded in archive	2022-11-14T10:40:42+00:00
Latest message date recorded in archive	2022-12-15T09:01:00+00:00
Message IDs present	4
Message IDs missing	0
Exact duplicate count	0
Original-file download availability	Original .mbox download available

Mailbox Message Index

Showing messages 1-4 of 4. Page 1 of 1. Public rendering is bounded to 25 message projections per page.

Index	Date	From	Subject	To	Attachment count	Parse status	Warning indicator
1	2022-12-15T09:01:00+00:00	Nick Moloney <nickdebrief@gmail.com>	Re: Registered Post	Donal Carroll <donal.carroll@hse.ie>	2	parsed_with_warnings	Yes
2	2022-12-14T14:21:22+00:00	"Carroll, Donal" <donal.carroll@hse.ie>	RE: Registered Post	Nick Moloney <nickdebrief@gmail.com>	4	parsed	No
3	2022-12-14T12:35:31+00:00	Nick Moloney <nickdebrief@gmail.com>	Fwd: Registered Post	Donal Carroll <donal.carroll@hse.ie>	2	parsed	No
4	2022-11-14T10:40:42+00:00	"Carroll, Donal" <donal.carroll@hse.ie>	Trust in care preliminary screening outcome	"nickdebrief@gmail.com" <nickdebrief@gmail.com>	2	parsed	No

Parser warnings: No mailbox-level parser warnings were recorded.

Cases

Case relationships are represented in the Relationship Graph when case references are present in the mailbox projection.

Timeline

Chronological access remains available through the Mailbox Message Index and message dates recorded in the preserved archive.

CDE Platform Stage 38C — Live Relationship Inspector Binding

The graph is generated deterministically from published mailbox projections. CDE Platform Stage 38C binds graph-node selection to live Relationship Inspector content through one selection pathway; it does not change relationship extraction or the graph API.

Relationship Graph Theme Standard High Contrast

Relationship Graph loading.

Person Institution Email Case Reference Attachment Intake Record

Message Detail

Mailbox message index	1
Message size	11451829
Contained-message digest	d8d91c26332ff0714eb95267b63814ef01987fd0f90c5e8285b82c9b5a57d8b9
Source byte range	52–11451881
Preview mode	file_backed_bounded
Preview truncated	Yes
Subject	Re: Registered Post
From	Nick Moloney <nickdebrief@gmail.com>
Sender	—
Reply-To	—
To	Donal Carroll <donal.carroll@hse.ie>
CC	"ULHOSPITALS, CEO" <ceoulhospitals@hse.ie>, "ceo.office@hse.ie" <ceo.office@hse.ie>, "stephen.donnelly@oireachtas.ie" <stephen.donnelly@oireachtas.ie>, "ministers_office@health.gov.ie" <ministers_office@health.gov.ie>, "Gloster, Bernard" <bernard.gloster@hse.ie>
Individual message date recorded in source	2022-12-15T09:01:00+00:00
Message-ID	<599F2298-B30B-46B0-B0AE-66DDED64D260@gmail.com>
In-Reply-To	—
References	<BDCD8E0D17A0D046AE0B8408463C9B92C01E4902@PLMKEXCMBX002.mw.intra>
MIME type	multipart/signed
Attachment count	2
Parser warnings	CloseBoundaryNotFoundDefect · MBOXLargeMessageFileBackedProjection · MBOXLargeMessagePreviewTruncated

Message Body

Good morning Donal, Thank you for you email. Open Disclosure... I received your email on 14 November 2022. I received your Registered Docket on 15 November 2022, attached. I received a call from Suzanne Begley 6 December 2022, attached: "How are you, Suzanne Begley is my name, I’m calling from the University Hospital in Limerick, I’m just looking for an email oh sorry a home address please to verify correspondence that I want to send out to you in the post. I’m calling from the University Hospital in Limerick. Say that again please, I can barely hear you, I apologise Ok, can you hear me, It’s my side that is bad, I’m looking for your home address for this correspondence that I want to issue to yourself and that’s from ourselves here in the hospital. It’s correspondence that is going to be issued to yourself And can you email it to me I can yes, what’s your email address nickdebrief@gmail.com Ok, That’s nickdebrief@gmail.com and can I take your home address as well so that I can also send in the post for you." I had to check the telephone number to find out where she was calling from, attached. 14 December 2022, received Registered Docket for collection a letter, attached. I Checked the first Registered Docket with RL548357444IE, attached. I checked the second Registered Docket with LD537227633BE, attached. I also checked An Post "Redeliveries can take approximately 3 to 5 working days to be delivered”. I received your email dated 14 December 2022, (Below) which confirms to me that after I spoke with Suzanne Begley on the 6 December 2022, Suzanne resent your letter via registered post again. Which does not reassure me to place my trust in care. Kind regards, Nick. > Begin forwarded message: > > From: "Carroll, Donal" <donal.carroll@hse.ie> > Subject: RE: Registered Post > Date: 14 December 2022 at 14:21:22 GMT > To: Nick Moloney <nickdebrief@gmail.com> > > Dear Mr Moloney, > > The document which was registered to you was the same document I attach and had previously issued to you by email on 14/11/2022. > > See other attachment for returned email which An Post failed to deliver. > > To confirm both the email and the hard copy(posted versions) were exactly the same. > > Regards > Donal > > From: Nick Moloney <nickdebrief@gmail.com <mailto:nickdebrief@gmail.com>> > Sent: Wednesday 14 December 2022 12:36 > To: Carroll, Donal <donal.carroll@hse.ie <mailto:donal.carroll@hse.ie>> > Subject: Fwd: Registered Post > > > > > Begin forwarded message: > > From: Nick Moloney <nickdebrief@gmail.com <mailto:nickdebrief@gmail.com>> > Subject: Registered Post > Date: 14 December 2022 at 11:54:48 GMT > To: "ULHOSPITALS, CEO" <ceoulhospitals@hse.ie <mailto:ceoulhospitals@hse.ie>> > Cc: ceo.office@hse.ie <mailto:ceo.office@hse.ie>, stephen.donnelly@oireachtas.ie <mailto:stephen.donnelly@oireachtas.ie>, ministers_office@health.gov.ie <mailto:ministers_office@health.gov.ie>, "Gloster, Bernard" <bernard.gloster@hse.ie <mailto:bernard.gloster@hse.ie>> > > Good morning, > > Please see attached file. > > Kind regards, > > Nick. > > > > Need information and advice on COVID-19? Go to www.hse.ie/coronavirus <https://www.hse.ie/coronavirus>

Sanitised HTML preview

Good morning Donal,

Thank you for you email.

Open Disclosure...

I received your email on 14 November 2022.

I received your Registered Docket on 15 November 2022, attached.

I received a call from Suzanne Begley 6 December 2022, attached:

"How are you, Suzanne Begley is my name, I’m calling from the University Hospital in Limerick, I’m just looking for an email oh sorry a home address please to verify correspondence that I want to send out to you in the post.

I’m calling from the University Hospital in Limerick.

Say that again please, I can barely hear you, I apologise

Ok, can you hear me, It’s my side that is bad, I’m looking for your home address for this correspondence that I want to issue to yourself and that’s from ourselves here in the hospital.

It’s correspondence that is going to be issued to yourself

And can you email it to me

I can yes, what’s your email address

nickdebrief@gmail.com

Ok, That’s nickdebrief@gmail.com and can I take your home address as well so that I can also send in the post for you."

I had to check the telephone number to find out where she was calling from, attached.

14 December 2022, received Registered Docket for collection a letter, attached.

I Checked the first Registered Docket with RL548357444IE, attached.

I checked the second Registered Docket with LD537227633BE, attached.

I also checked An Post "Redeliveries can take approximately 3 to 5 working days to be delivered”.

I received your email dated 14 December 2022, (Below) which confirms to me that after I spoke with Suzanne Begley on the 6 December 2022, Suzanne resent your letter via registered post again.

Which does not reassure me to place my trust in care.

Kind regards,

Nick.

Begin forwarded message:

From: "Carroll, Donal" <donal.carroll@hse.ie>

Subject: RE: Registered Post

Date: 14 December 2022 at 14:21:22 GMT

To: Nick Moloney <nickdebrief@gmail.com>

Dear Mr Moloney,

The document which was registered to you was the same document I attach and had previously issued to you by email on 14/11/2022.

See other attachment for returned email which An Post failed to deliver.

To confirm both the email and the hard copy(posted versions) were exactly the same.

Attachments

Attachments remain components of the preserved MBOX archive unless separately admitted through Document Intake.

Filename	Media type	Byte size	Disposition	Content ID	Attached message
Call Received 6 December 2022.pdf	application/pdf	105370	inline	—	No
Registered Docket 14 December 2022.jpg	image/jpeg	263093	inline	—	No

Mailbox Governance Boundary

Download original .mbox

Publication Provenance

Publication provenance records the administrative pathway by which this document became publicly available through CDE. It does not certify the document’s legal status, evidential truth, authorship, or external validation.

Intake date and time: 2026-09-01T11:47:28.630440Z
Intake mode: Governed Streaming Mailbox Intake
Streaming upload started: 2026-09-01T11:47:28.101496Z
Streaming upload completed: 2026-09-01T11:47:28.435004Z
Streaming validation completed: 2026-09-01T11:47:28.618064Z
Streaming finalisation timestamp: 2026-09-01T11:47:28.630440Z
Configured streaming limit: 1073741824 bytes
Document date: 2022-11-14
Server-detected document format: MBOX Mailbox Archive
Detected MBOX variant: mboxo
MBOX message count: 4
Outlook archive type: —
Outlook parser status: —
Outlook parser version: —
Outlook preservation complete: —
Outlook hash verification status: —
Outlook inspection complete: —
Outlook inspection timestamp: —
Outlook projection state: —
Outlook archive job identifier: —
Archive source: —
Gmail Takeout parser version: —
Gmail Takeout preservation complete: —
Gmail Takeout projection state: —
Archive source: —
IMAP acquisition timestamp: —
IMAP acquisition hash: —
IMAP preservation complete: —
IMAP projection state: —
Original filename: mbox.mbox
File size: 18702707 bytes
SHA-256 digest: 8d8d83881b11fb9f700208fb7a18c7fa78c4a7056b78933331012bbabf668630
SHA-512 digest: —
Document Identifier: DOC-2026-000431
Current lifecycle: Original lifecycle
Initial intake actor: nick
Review actor: nick
Approval actor: nick
Publication actor: nick
Review timestamp: —
Approval timestamp: —
Publication timestamp: 2026-09-01T11:51:15.887810Z
Current lifecycle state: Published
Optional Reference Identifier: ULHG-COM.4338
Public presentation mode: Mailbox archive metadata, paginated message inspection, safe body previews, and original-file download
Original-file download availability: Original .mbox download available

The SHA-256 digest identifies the exact original bytes admitted through Document Intake. It supports byte-level comparison of the preserved file but does not independently establish authorship, factual accuracy, legal status, or external authenticity.

Publication Pathway

Original lifecycle

Timestamp	Previous status	New status	Actor	Note
2026-09-01T11:47:28.630440Z	Initial state	Pending Intake	nick	Document uploaded to pending intake through Governed Streaming Mailbox Intake.
2026-09-01T11:49:05.638249Z	Pending Intake	Under Review	nick	Successful streaming intake establishes that the source was processed within the governed pathway. It does not verify the correspondence, endorse the preliminary-screening outcome or determine the meaning, reliability or legal effect of any preserved material.
2026-09-01T11:50:17.152422Z	Under Review	Approved	nick	Approval confirms the integrity and acceptability of the preserved mailbox source. It does not verify the truth of its contents, endorse the preliminary-screening outcome, treat repeated material as independent corroboration or determine the evidential or legal effect of any correspondence.
2026-09-01T11:51:15.887810Z	Approved	Published	nick	Publication confirms that the reviewed mailbox is an accepted, preserved source within the platform. Its visibility remains Private. Publication does not make the mailbox publicly accessible, verify its contents, endorse the preliminary-screening outcome or determine the evidential or legal effect of any message or attachment.

Actor identifies the administrative identity recorded for the lifecycle action. It does not by itself establish authorship, factual verification, or legal responsibility for the document contents.